Top 12 Covers that Outperformed The Original Songs

Orchestra Central is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Cover songs are usually a nod to already awesome songs. But sometimes, the renditions end up being more popular than the original. Over the decades, there have been a lot of remakes. Here are 12 outstanding covers that were so good that people though they were the original version.

Respect by Aretha Franklin

Rome February 10 2020: Cd And Artwork Of The Icon
Source: Shutterstock

Respect was originally by Otis Redding, but Aretha Franklin’s version made it a world sensation. “Aretha Franklin had a habit of taking a song and making it better, that’s for sure,” writes a commentator. 

All Along the Watch Tower by Jimi Hendrix

Rome Italy January 20 2021 Cd The Jimi Hendrix
Source: Shutterstock

This song is by the legendary American singer-songwriter Bob Dylan, but fans agree that Jimi Hendrix’s version was better. Interestingly, Dylan also acknowledged that Jimi’s version was better. 

Where Did You Sleep Last Night by Nirvana

Rome Italy August 05 2021 Detail Of The Cover
Source: Shutterstock

Originally by Lead Belly, Nirvana brings this old song back to life with his cover. “I find the Nirvana version to be haunting and beautiful,” reads a post. 

Istanbul (Not Constantinople) By They Might Be Giants

Barcelona Jun 30: They Might Be Giants (band) Perform
Source: Shutterstock

“I had no idea that was a cover! I loved that song when TMBG put it out. I just listened to the original, and yes, TMBG’s cover of it is better,” explains a fan. The song was originally by The Four Lads. 

I Love Rock and Roll by Joan Jett

Sacramento Ca December 4: Joan Jett Of Joan Jett
Source: Shutterstock

Joan Jett also does an incredible job singing The Arrow’s song: I Love Rock and Roll. A user says, “The Arrow’s version sounds so much dirtier for some reason, even though it’s the same song with the pronouns reversed.” 

Tainted Love by Soft Cell

Miami Fl Usa: June 2021: Synth Pop And New Wave Band
Source: Shutterstock

“Most people do not know that the original was recorded by Gloria Jones in 1964. But it was Soft Cell who made it great in 1981,” reads a post.

1985 by Bowling for Soup

Bowling For Soup Live At O2 Victoria Warehouse Manchester Uk
Source: Shutterstock

“That’s a cover?” asks a commentator. Indeed. This song was originally by SR-71 and written by Mitch Allen. 

Black Magic Woman by Santana

Napa Ca/usa: 5/26/19: Carlos Santana Performs At Bottlerock. A Mexican
Source: Shutterstock

This song was originally by Peter Green, the founder of Fleetwood Mac. But Santana’s version is leagues better for some online fans. One fan says, “Santana made the music cry as he played it. Not too many have that skill.”

Torn by Natalie Imbruglia

Budapest Hungary Aug 12: Australian Pop Singer Natalie
Source: Shutterstock

Natalie also did a fantastic cover of Lis Sorensen’s song, Torn“That’s a devastating song. You can really feel it when she sings it,” explains a post.  

Hallelujah by Jeff Buckley

Cluj Napoca Romania January 25 2023 Detail Of Jeff
Source: Shutterstock

“I love this rendition; it’s beautiful,” states a commentator. Many users feel this is a great funeral song and have had it played during the celebration of life or when lowering the casket in the grave. Hallelujah was originally by Leonard Cohen. 

I Heard It Through the Grapevine by Marvin Gaye

Rome September 19 2020: Cd And Artwork By Soul Singer
Source: Shutterstock

Gladys Knight is the original singer of I Heard It Through the Grapevine. But we cannot fail to mention Marvin Gaye’s part in creating a beautiful rendition.  

I Will Always Love You by Whitney Houston

Rome Italy April 23 2020 Whitney Cd Cover The
Source: Shutterstock

This list would be incomplete without Whitney Houston’s cover of I Will Always Love You“This song was a number 1 hit in 3 decades,” points out a user. And it was originally recorded by Dolly Parton. 

Source: Reddit
Featured Photo from Shutterstock

10 Worst Band Names in the History of Rock and Roll

Woman Shocked
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

10 Worst Band Names in the History of Rock and Roll

10 Greatest Rock Bands of All Time

Magdeburg Germany January 15 2022: Record Cover Of The
queen
Source: Shutterstock

10 Greatest Rock Bands of All Time

20 Most Famous Guitarists of All Time

Joe Satriani Rocks Up Concert In Shanghai
Photo by ChinaImages on Deposit Photos

20 Most Famous Guitarists of All Time

10 Rock Songs With Secret Meanings and Hidden Messages You Probably Missed

Man Listening To Music Frightened
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

10 Rock Songs With Secret Meanings and Hidden Messages You Probably Missed

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here