10 Greatest Rock Bands of All Time, According to Redditors

Orchestra Central is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Perennial discussion about the greatest rock bands of all time is a hallmark on many forums. Conversation threads on this highly debated topic always emerge on Reddit, and they are always fun to evaluate. Let’s take a look at Redditor’s choices for the greatest rock bands of all time.

Pink Floyd

Madrid,,spain, ,april,18:,cover,of,the,album,dark
Editorial credit: Enriscapes / Shutterstock.com

They did not invent psychedelic rock, but they certainly made it radio-friendly and unforgettable. What is interesting about this band, which has been around since 1967, is that it continues to draw new listeners. One British Redditor asserts: “I’m 13 and they’re are my favourite.”

The Beatles

London United Kingdom May 25 2016: The Beatles In
Source: Shutterstock

No list of the greatest rock bands of all time could be complete without The Beatles. This seems to be a Reddit consensus about The Beatles, a band synonymous with legendary rock. “There are bands I like more than them, but they are by far the greatest band of all time.” 

Led Zeppelin

Robert Plant Jimmy Page And John Paul Jones At The
Source: Shutterstock

“Individually, they are each possibly the most talented musicians on their instruments. And they write well together.” A common theme among Redditors who mention this British band is how talented they were. 


Universal City Ca June 22: Geddy Lee Of The
Source: Shutterstock

This Canadian group stands out in a sea of legendary American and British bands. Rush plays the kind of music that sounds epic with and without synthesizers. “The evolution and diversity of this band is unmatched. The live shows were incredible and the lyrics intelligent.” 


Magdeburg Germany €“ January 15 2022: Record Cover Of The
Source: Shutterstock

Queen did not invent stadium rock, but they made it cool. The sheer musical genius of the late Freddie Mercury made this band legendary. “In terms of reach across generations and fans of different genres, there can be no other answer.”

Van Halen

Alex Van Halen And David Lee Roth With Eddie Van
Source: Shutterstock

Some people mostly know Van Halen from the drama involving lead singers David Lee Roth and Sammy Hagar. But the death of guitar virtuoso Eddie Van Halen in 2020 caused younger Reddit users to discover his music. As one Redditor puts it: “I’ve never heard music by any of the answers other than Van Halen.”

The Who

Pittsburgh Pa March 16 2016 : Roger Daltry And
Source: Shutterstock

The rock opera album “Tommy” was released more than five decades ago, forming the blueprint for punk rock. Members of Led Zeppelin, Pink Floyd, and Rush often mention that this British band was their greatest influence.

Alice in Chains

Alice In Chains Performance At Rock Werchter Festival Werchter Belgium
Source: Shutterstock

Nostalgic interest in the pop culture of the 1990s has put this Seattle rock band on Reddit’s radar. One Redditor prefers Alice in Chains to Nirvana because “their lyrics had so much meaning then.” Interestingly enough, American classic rock stations have been adding grunge to their playlists since 2015.

Credence Clearwater Revival

Viersen,,germany, ,may,9.,2021:,closeup,of,creedence,clearwater
Photo by Ralf Liebhold on Shutterstock

 Since 1978, CCR has been included in the soundtracks of about a dozen Hollywood films about the Vietnam War. The masterful CCR combination of blues, boogie, soul, and acid rock always sounds great. According to a Redditor who also likes Led Zeppelin and The Beatles, “IMO the greatest American Rock Band ever.” 

Black Sabbath

Los Angeles Jan 26: Black Sabbath Ozzy Osbourne Arrives
Source: Shutterstock

 “Sabbath and Zeppelin were two sides of the same coin. They were both the best at what they did,” one Redditor comments. Similar to other bands of their time, Black Sabbath admired American blues musicians, and they tried to emulate them.

This thread inspired this post.

Featured Photo from Shutterstock.

20 Most Famous Guitarists of All Time

Guitarist Kirk Hammett Of Metallica During Performance In Prague, Czech Republic, May 7, 2012.
Photo by yakub88 on Deposit Photos

20 Most Famous Guitarists of All Time

10 Hardest Musical Instruments to Learn

Drum Set

10 Hardest Musical Instruments to Learn

Best Guitar Solos of All Time

Joe Satriani Rocks Up Concert In Shanghai
Photo by ChinaImages on Deposit Photos

30 Best Guitar Solos of All Time

20 Best Concerts Boomers Have Been To

East,rutherford,,nj/usa, ,august,1,,2019:,singer,mick,jagger
Editorial credit: Bruce Alan Bennett / Shutterstock.com

20 Best Concerts Boomers Have Been To


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here