From Garage Bands to Grammy Winners: How Big Is the Musical Gap?

A coming-of-age milestone growing up in ‘90s Britain was joining a band with your friends. It mattered little how much talent you had (or whether you could even play an instrument correctly); it was all about the vibe and tribalism of youth — or something like that. The dream of countless teenagers is to be a rock star, and a recent online discussion highlights the differences between recording artists and garage band upstarts. How many amateur musicians could make it as a pro?

The Gulf Between Class Levels

Classical Concert
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

The original poster shares their interpretation of talent by using an NBA analogy, saying how the gulf between the top college level and professional level is vast. Surely, the same must be said of musicians? From a non-musician perspective, the comparison isn’t easy, so what did accomplished musos have to say?

Keeping Things Tight

Belgrade, Serbia - June 29th: Singer Mike Patton of American band Faith No More performing on Belgrade Calling festival on June 29th 2012, in Belgrade, Serbia
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

A local music club staff member says every type of act graced their stage, from Berklee Kids to high school metal bands. In their opinion, professional musicians are performance-tight in a way other musicians are not. The thousands of hours required to reach the top give the pros the edge over newcomers.

The Elite Ranking System

Man Writing Music For New Album
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Musical ability is a hierarchy, though some may bristle at the existence of a “who’s the best” hypothetical. We classify guitarists as simple beginner, intermediate, or advanced status, but this changes once you hit the big time. Many observers argue that session musicians deserve a category above the advanced level: professional, master, or virtuoso.

They Hear Everything

Traditionally Austrian Musicians
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

A self-trained musician reveals how he joined a band full of professional session musicians, and even his years of writing, touring, and recording pales compared to their natural ability. They can pick up things on the fly, recite parts for the first time without practice, and hear “everything” you do wrong.

The Importance of Self-Care

Man Drumming
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Real musicians (vocalists included) take great care of their instruments. For example, a top drummer will re-skin their drums regularly, tune them to perfection, and calibrate each part to its best working condition. Likewise, professional vocalists don’t merely show up and start singing lest they damage their voice. They take a long time warming up each vocal chord, and if they detect a hint of strain, they may even call the performance off.

Great in Theory

Musical Theory
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Professional musicians complete over ten thousand hours of discipline to become the best, and this usually covers much theory-based learning. Those unaware of musical theory can be overwhelmed when pros discuss their terminology without a second thought.

All in the Release

Recording
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

We all know how tight professional musicians are onstage, and sometimes, it can feel like listening to a recording. However, small nuances play a part in musical performance, especially when recording. The release of a note is almost as crucial as the note itself; even the way you hit a drum alters its sound.

Running Circles Around the Rest

Music Teacher Teaching To Students
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Another anecdote involves an amateur musicians’ group that joins twice a week to jam in their local music hall. Each week, a retired professional session musician joins them, picking up any instrument lying around, and he still schools everyone. One could argue that musicianship is one of the few arts in which age is no detriment to progress.

Play It by Ear

BENICASIM, SPAIN - JULY 21: The Killers band concert performance at FIB (Festival Internacional de Benicassim) 2013 Festival on July 21, 2013 in Benicasim, Spain.
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

A great video on YouTube reveals Megadeth drummer Dirk Verbeuren listening to a drumless version of The Killers’ “Mr Brightside” once before writing his version. The level of natural and learned skill is alarming, with Verbeuren’s version arguably superior to Mark Stoermer’s original drum track.

The Food Analogy

Musicians Discussing
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

A great analogy for music (one I have always enjoyed) is musicians being like cookery. Can you compare a short-order cook to a Michelin-star chef? A pro chef must turn out the same flawless, world-class dishes each day for hours, much like a session musician on tour. It doesn’t matter about ingredients so much, though we all know the best chefs choose the best ingredients, much like musicians buy the best instruments.

Not Just About Practice

Drummer Practicing
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Sadly, some lifelong musicians can practice to a professional level only for some upstart with no training to upstage them. For example, Buddy Rich is considered by many as the greatest drummer ever, and he was self-taught with nothing more than pure talent. While the gap is big on average, some musical outliers deserve freak-of-nature status.

Source: Reddit.

10 Worst Band Names in the History of Rock and Roll

Woman Shocked
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

10 Worst Band Names in the History of Rock and Roll

Why Can’t You Play Stairway To Heaven In Guitar Stores?

guitar

Why Can’t You Play Stairway To Heaven In Guitar Stores?

10 Greatest Rock Bands of All Time

Magdeburg Germany January 15 2022: Record Cover Of The
queen
Source: Shutterstock

10 Greatest Rock Bands of All Time

20 Most Famous Guitarists of All Time

Joe Satriani Rocks Up Concert In Shanghai
Photo by ChinaImages on Deposit Photos

20 Most Famous Guitarists of All Time

10 Rock Songs With Secret Meanings and Hidden Messages You Probably Missed

Man Listening To Music Frightened
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

10 Rock Songs With Secret Meanings and Hidden Messages You Probably Missed

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here